John Tucker Must Die (12A)

Film image

The ViewLondon Review

StarStarStarNo StarNo Star
Review byMatthew Turner15/08/2006

Three out of Five stars
Running time: 93 mins

Not quite in the league of Mean Girls but this is still an enjoyably silly teen revenge comedy with strong performances and a witty, likeable script.

What's it all about?
Jesse Metcalfe (from Desperate Housewives) stars as John Tucker, a high school lothario who dates girls from different cliques so they don't find out about each other. However, when three of his simultaneous girlfriends (brainy over-achiever Arielle Kebbel, sassy cheerleader Ashanti and slutty vegan activist Sophia Bush) find out they decide to get their revenge on John and publicly humiliate him.

The girls' scheme involves doing a makeover on overlooked new girl Kate (Brittany Snow) so that John will fall in love with her and she can then break his heart. However, the plan backfires when Kate (from whose perspective the story is told) finds herself falling for John, which in turn jeopardises her burgeoning relationship with John's cute younger brother Scott (Penn Badgley).

The Good
This isn't as dark, as witty or as inventive as Mean Girls or Heathers (its two obvious inspirations) but it has an attractive cast and some genuinely funny moments. Metcalfe gamely sends up his frequently shirtless hunk du jour image and, crucially, ensures that Tucker remains sympathetic, despite his womanising ways.

Snow is a real find; she's extremely cute and has superb comic timing. Here's hoping her career really takes off after this. Kebbel and Ashanti are good too, but Sophia Bush steals the film because her character gets all the best lines.

The Bad
The only real problem with John Tucker Must Die is that supposedly invisible Kate is attractive and funny in her own right, so you can't quite believe John wouldn't have noticed her. Similarly, all the girls really do in the makeover is to straighten her hair and make her a cheerleader.

Worth seeing?
This is an enjoyable comedy with attractive performances but it might have been more fun if it had been as dark as its title suggests.

Film Trailer

John Tucker Must Die (12A)
Be the first to review John Tucker Must Die...
image
01 Serena (15)

Jennifer Lawrence, Bradley Cooper

image
02 Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day (tbc)

Steve Carell, Jennifer Garner, Dylan Minnette, Ed ...

image
03 The Second Best Marigold Hotel (12)

Maggie Smith, Judi Dench, Celia Imrie, Richard Ger...

image
04 Home (PG)

Jim Parsons, Rihanna, Jennifer Lopez

image
05 Fury (15)

Brad Pitt, Shia LaBeouf, Logan Lerman

Content updated: 25/10/2014 00:04

Latest Film Reviews

Film of the Week

Fury (15)

Brad Pitt and his tank crew have to battle their way through war torn Germany after four years of hard fighting.

UK Box Office Top 5 Films