Gaucho Piccadilly

User rating 

StarStarStarStarNo Star

 17 reviews

Venue Image
25 Swallow Street,
Piccadilly,
London,
W1B 4QR

0871 971 6803
Note: Calls cost 10p per min plus network extras.

Add a User Review for

Gaucho Piccadilly
Add user review button
Add your own review of this restaurant
Sort By:
User icon
StarStarStarStarNo Star
Reviewer bobby johnson
06/04/2010
An absolutely spectacular venue, great food, great service and a reasonable price (for west end), I would recommend it to any and all meat eaters!
Reply to this review
User icon
StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer Mrs Dennison
12/10/2009
Abysmal experience. Never ever again. It was our second time there and I can confirm that it has gone way downhill.

Overpriced below average food, awful service, overcrowded, very loud speed-you-up music piped in while you eat.

I booked a table for 4 -all in our 30s-, Saturday 10th October 2009 for 9:45. We were given our table well passed 11pm. The table service was awful.

Flustered and rude waitress got orders wrong, took my husbands credit card away from us with the pin number in! and did not return for a while.

The couple next to us arrived later than us and the waitress took their order and served them before us.If you are thinking about it, don't.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Onntherock
09/10/2009
Superb complimentary lovely cheese soft bread, starters platter, main course which we ordered the most expensive jurasco and rib eye steak, very nice desssert -panacotta and great presentation from the waitress.

It was our first time so the big plate that shows the different of each type of steaks, from raw meat so we can see texture and finally we chose what we really wanted for, it does help a lot after i wasn't too sure between sirloin or rib eyes.

The comis or maybe the food runner was not so good from her poor english. And she took some plates away without asking if we finish which is not so professional. I understand she wasn't mean to be rude. So i can let it slide.

What I like most is how they trained their waiter and waitress. I feel like they are attentive and in the perfect level. Not too much and whenever we want something, there's always some staff around.

Its not only for one time but surprisingly every time from any waiter/waitress who serve us.The bill came up with the price that obviously not moderate but its worth to pay comparing to the service and food quality. There's surprisingly no service charge which is very rare in these days.

Only one thing that I wasnt impressed is group booking. I was once planning to have my birthday dinner with my friends, 8 of us. But we cant order food as a la carte, only set menu available and the price range is a bit over the top.

I know because I go there a lot and always have 3 courses meal plus cocktail in the beginning, water, soda and finish the meal up with coffee or tea. And the price per person from that full options meal is still less than group set price. It doesn't make any sense for me.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer flamingo
13/10/2008
We went to the Gaucho on a busy saturday evening without a reservation and waited around 40 minutes for a table. This wasn't a problem though, as we sat in the (dark) bard had some very good, but expensive, cocktails.

When seated, the extremely abrupt waitress insulted one of us and the appauling service continued throughout, with her making snotty remarks. Whilst I understand the pressure of a busy service, there is no need for the attitude of the staff, acting like it is an inconvenience to serve you.

The food was good, but for the price of the meal, I would have expected first class service.... unfortunately all the staff seemed to busy to be bothered.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer angeltott
25/08/2008
Does noone else pick up on the fact that the tables are never 'ready' when arriving? You promptly get escorted to the pitch black bar where you are left no choice but racking up an extra £15-£20 on drinks you didn't plan to have in the first place.
Now, I understand this is an easy way for Gaucho to increase revenue because most people probably fail to reflect over this as they're probably quite happy just to have got a table in the first place.
As for me, I'd like to decide what I'd like to spend my money on, not being put in a situation where I have no choice.

However, once in the restaurant, we had a pleasant enough evening.
Service was quick, informative and efficient but unfortunately not much more than that.
This place is a machine and it runs like clockwork.
It's fascinating to watch, creating an experience that is not just culinary.

On the flipside,
the live band is fantastic, steaks divine and the wine list very reasonable.

Gaucho seem to have forgotten about the customer, it rather seems that we should be grateful to be able to take part of the spectable which is this crazy maze of an operation rather than being treated like valued and welcomed diners.

Will I go back? No, not in a hurry.
Great steaks can be had in many other restaurants which have not lost their soul or identity for the favour of a money machine.


Reply to this review
User icon
StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer Anonymous
18/08/2008
I have been visiting both the Picadilly and Chelsea Gaucho Grills for about 5 years now.

My past three dinners at the Picadilly branch have been hugely dissappointing and unfortunately we won't be back again. Compared to the other branches, I find the steaks here have become tough and tasteless and it might be due to the large amount of stock they would need to purchase in order to feed a larger restaurant. This is since their refurbishment. There is a reason why the best restaurants cater for smaller groups of people.

Besides for the inferior meat, our hummitas have been served cold twice now and on the one occassion the waiter even admitted that they just forgot to warm it up. This indicates that the food is pre-prepared and not fresh.

I would highly recommend Gaucho's in Chelsea but steer clear of the branch in Picadilly, which in my view is spoiling the reputation of this once great chain of restaurants!
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer joshdh
25/03/2008
Gaucho is an excellent restaurant. Great service and the steaks were out of this world.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Lyndalou
26/10/2007
I went to Gaucho on a busy Saturday evening and can honestly say I had the best steak I have ever eaten. The staff were incredibly friendly and welcoming, our waiter was attentive and knowledgeable and the atmosphere was perfect. I ordered a fillet steak and have never tasted anything so tender, creamy and delicious. I only wish I had gone for a larger steak. Bearnaise sauce was nice, but unnecessary - the steak needed nothing else. Starters and desserts are also good, especially the dulce de lech cheesecake, but my advise is to order the biggest steak you can eat as the flavours are amazing. My two friends are critical about every restaurant we visit, but for once, they had nothing but praise for their entire meal. I would highly recommend this restaurant. I only visit London once or twice a year, but will definitely be going back to the Gaucho Grill.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarNo StarNo StarNo StarNo Star
Reviewer presendo
16/10/2007
I went to Gaucho with a group of around 20 people. We had to have the set menu. From our experience, all our group was pretty disappointed with the food and service. We had to return our steaks in order to have them rare or well done as ordered, chase waiters for service and they did not even have proper cutlery to cut the meat. As a Brazilian with great experience in the Barbecue area..I was pretty disappointed as well the whole group. The dark chocolate tart was so bitter that it was uneatable.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
21/05/2007
Gaucho Grill was amazing! My fiance ordered a medium rare steak it was perfect, I do not eat beef as I dont like the taste. He told me to close my eyes and gave me some. It was lovely, really creamy and velvety! 20 years since I have eaten beef! Wine was superb and service second to none. Thanks for making our evening so great! Value for money was excellent. Starter, meals, dessert, wine and coffees for £80! We will be back. Thank you Gaucho Grill.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
06/11/2006
I have to confess to being a Gaucho Grill addict! The steaks never fail to impress and the side orders are delicious enough to eat on their own. The service at Gaucho Grill is always the right mix between friendly and unobtrusive. If you like good quality steak - go. You're missing out if you don't.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer xyz671
26/10/2006
The Gaucho Grill was excellent. The food was amazing food, with a first class service at a reasonable price; you couldn’t ask for more. Many thanks to our Gaucho Grill waitress who made the night a special one.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
24/11/2005
Four of us went to the Gaucho Grill and the boss was paying! Even if he wasn't the food was a very reasonable price. The atmosphere at Gaucho Grill is great as you walk into a little underground cavern with subdued lighting falling on the fake ponyskin seating.


The steak is out of this world and for someone who does not like fish, the salmon Ceviche was excellent.


Service was fairly swift and the waiter was very polite even though his uniform looked more like a strait jacket. The only complaint would be price of the cheeseboard which offered the thinnest slices of cheese we had ever seen!

Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
26/04/2005
Gaucho Grill is not a place or veggies. This is 100% Argentinian beef on your plate and no excuses.
The Gaucho Grill do the best meat in London - go visit.
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
10/11/2004
Perfect lazy Sunday lunch at the Gaucho Grill. Fantastic staff, who couldn't do enough to help, great food and spot-on atmosphere.


Simple stuff done well. Having put a couple of lousy reviews on ViewLondon for other places, felt it was time to praise somewhere that 'worked'.

Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
19/07/2004
The Gaucho Grill has great food, great atmosphere and very friendly staff. All in all a fantastic night out. Well recomended
Reply to this review
User icon
StarStarStarStarStar
Reviewer Anonymous
20/03/2004
If you love red meat, Gaucho Grill is a must! I went yesterday evening and enjoyed the most tasty "lomo" I ever had in London. With a choice of good side orders and dessert I will definitely go back asap!
Reply to this review
The views contained in these user reviews are not endorsed by ViewLondon in any way and are provided by users who wish to publish their independent views of the respective establishment.

Most Read Today

image
01 Queens Jubilee Bank Holiday Events

Celebrate Her Majesty's 60 year reign with a four ...

image
02 Thames Diamond Jubilee River Pageant

See over a thousand boats sail the Thames to celeb...

image
03 Queens Diamond Jubilee London

Celebrate the Diamond Jubilee in 2012 as the capit...

image
04 Summer in London

Free music festivals, arts and culture, pools, par...

image
05 Queens Jubilee Thames Flotilla

Cheer on the Queen as she leads a thousand boats a...

Content updated: 30/05/2012 13:31
Follow us on Twitter and Facebook

Restaurant Hire

Planning a party?

Find a special restaurant to make your party special here.

.

This Week Try With A View® Card

Khanage

2-4-1 food courses Sunday to Thursday with View® Card.

Latest Restaurants User Reviews

  • Planet Hollywood
    this isn't a review but I don't know where else write or ask for ...
    StarStarStarNo StarNo Star
    Dally9 on 30/05/2012 @ 11:16
  • Standard Balti House
    SBH is the best, every occasion that we are there it has been a v...
    StarStarStarStarStar
    Anabanna on 30/05/2012 @ 00:22
  • Roadhouse
    Went here on Saturday to celebrate my sisters 30th. We got in ear...
    StarStarNo StarNo StarNo Star
    allybear on 29/05/2012 @ 23:23
  • Sushi des Artistes
    Everyone must try! Went there with my girlfriend last weekend. ...
    StarStarStarStarStar
    philip.green on 29/05/2012 @ 18:33
  • Takari
    Wow as i return from a party booked at Takari I must write a note...
    StarStarStarStarStar
    susan_binder1 on 29/05/2012 @ 00:21